No, you shouldn't wear a tie with a short-sleeved shirt. Ties are formal accessories typically worn with long-sleeved dress shirts. You'll create a style mismatch if you wear a short-sleeved shirt with a tie.
Once you knot a tie over a short sleeve shirt, you'll have created an awkward style imbalance. The combination of bare arms contrasted by a tied closed neck looks unflattering and inappropriate. You can easily picture the formality of the tie clashing with the casual nature of the short sleeves.
There are situations, such as in tropical climates, where short sleeves may be worn under a jacket or suit with a tie, but even in these situations, the pairing isn't ideal. During hot summers or if you're heading to a sultry locale for vacation where you want to stay comfortable while looking sharp, choose an open-collared short sleeve shirt without a tie — or opt for a lightweight long-sleeved shirt in an open airy weave if a tie is required.
Explore The Tie Bar's collection of formal and casual ties designed to pair seamlessly with the right shirt styles.
More from the Tie Bar Journal
Unlock a world of style inspiration, fashion insights, and expert advice to elevate your menswear game. From style novices to seasoned fashionistas, there's something for everyone.

Shop Talk: Feeling Your Best with Medo Redzic
Relentless Barbershop sits in the middle of downtown Chicago and is meant to make you look and feel your best, both in the chair and as you’re heading out the door.

Flannel to Chalk Stripe: A Wool Survival Guide
How to pick, wear, and style the wool suit that keeps you cozy in winter while keeping your reputation sharp.